Generally Speaking

Brexit: not the will of the people – my 2017 post summarised by AI

People are still claiming that the 2016 EU referendum demonstrated ‘the will of the people’. Meanwhile, not a single person has ever challenged my 2017 post claiming that this is simply not true – perhaps because it was too long. So I have just used the AI feature of the ideas-modelling application TheBrain to produce what I hope will be a helpful summary. Here it is, exactly as generated:


Britain’s Exit from the EU

  • Misleading Campaigns: The Leave campaign allegedly used lies, incited xenophobia, and dismissed expert opinions.
  • Public Misunderstanding: Many voters were unaware of the EU’s complexities and implications.
  • Subsequent Developments: Changes in the global political landscape, such as Trump’s election, have altered the context.
  • Unforeseen Consequences: The Brexit process has not been smooth, with negative impacts on the NHS and economic negotiations.
  • Democratic Concerns: Issues like data mining, dark money, and media influence may have skewed the democratic process.
  • Electoral Issues: A significant portion of the electorate did not vote for Brexit, and polls suggest a shift towards Remain.

The author expresses concern over the divisive and potentially undemocratic nature of the Brexit process, emphasizing the need for responsible debate and reflection on the broader implications for democracy and society.


Direct link to the original 2017 post to see the arguments in full, and the reactions.

ACAN – 5 incredible years

INTRODUCTION James

We are here this evening to celebrate ACAN, and to thank the three people who have comprised its Core Group from its inception, who have now announced their intention to stand down. We warmly welcome the Alton Town Mayor, Town and East Hampshire District Councillors, and all our other guests, especially the new ACAN trustees.
In the next half hour or so, Sue and I will be attempting the impossible – to do some sort of justice to the extraordinary achievements and value of this organisation, which held its first public meeting at the Assembly Rooms on the 14th June 2019

Read more…

Schrödinger’s anaemia


I see, I think I understand now – you don’t know what’s wrong.

He’s got it.

He’s here in my evening surgery to find out why the consultant he saw this morning wants him straight in hospital.  Something about “ulcers”.  Grey, anxious face.  Deep lines deeper.  Brave, frightened eyes.

Time to recap before he leaves to face the weekend’s wait. “Three reasons you could be anaemic . . .”  Tick off the fingers.  “. . . it could be your arthritis doing it all by itself, it could be the new tablets affecting your bone marrow, or it could be the Naproxen giving you an ulcer in your stomach which is bleeding.

Read more…

A Gîte in Brittany

It was never my intention that this should be a travel blog, but I’ve only written one post since our trip up the length of the Outer Hebrides this May and now we are in Brittany and I have things I would like to say.

It’s not that there hasn’t been a lot going on and, potentially, to write about; more a question of being overwhelmed by the seriousness of those events, at home and in the world, and the fact that they are written about so copiously already.

Travelogues are safe, fun, provide a useful record for me, and possibly provide interest and entertainment for others – or even, it would be nice to think, useful information. After all, my daily posts from our Golden Wedding anniversary trip up the West Coast of North America were by far the most ‘liked’ pages in this entire blog, and the recent Hebridean ones are not that far behind.

The contemporary assaults on objective truth, public morality, and climate science, just for starters, are infinitely more important, and I will probably have another shot at making a contribution some time when I have the strength/inspiration. But for the moment, let’s stick to recreation, and my and my wife’s incredible good fortune in having such opportunities open to us.

200 miles south and one time-zone forward.
(Screen grab from Google Earth)

So, as I start this piece, we are here in South Brittany, France. Bretagne to the French, hence Grande Bretagne, hence GB or ‘Great Britain’, which therefore has nothing to do with boasting about ‘greatness’, much as Last Night of the Proms flag-wavers might imagine, it is more that when the Normans arrived, a thousand years ago, and brought with them their language, the new Britain was bigger than the Bretagne they came from. (Not that it is bigger than France, needless to say; in that case it is the other way round.)

So here we are, in our little gîte. Gîtes, by the way, are privately-rented holiday cottages situated all over France. Long pre-dating AirB&B and the internet, they are typically quite basic conversions of old farm buildings in rural situations.

Read more…

Xit

Goodbye Twitter. RIP. You are now X Twitter. I’ll miss you. Honest injun.

Opposite is my final tweet after many years. Posted a couple of weeks ago. And as usual, apart from from one or two old friends, it didn’t attract much attention – at least not in the few hours before I worked out how to delete my account. (You ‘deactivate’ it and it is wiped clean, so it says, a month later. Phutt…)

So if any of the 332 ‘followers’ I somehow built up over the years have found their way to this humble blog then welcome indeed. I will try to remember to ‘enable comments’ when I write these things so that we can chat about them  Sometimes. Perhaps. If you want to.

Read more…

Space is Big

The late, great Douglas Adams put it like this:

Space is big. Really big. You just won’t believe how vastly hugely mindbogglingly big it is...”

Thus began the The Hitchhikers’ Guide to the Galaxy – voiced in Peter Jones’ wonderful deadpan for the original 1974 BBC Radio 4 series:

…I mean you may think it’s a long way down the road to the chemist, but that’s just peanuts to space. Listen… and so on‘.

An item in this week’s New Scientist gives you another way of looking at this. Apparently, cosmologists are excited by the discovery (by an amateur astronomer, yay!) of the nearest supernova to us that anyone has seen for years. It’s billed on the front cover as BACKYARD SUPERNOVA. They say this is going to give us a ringside seat as the explosion develops over the next months and years so that we can learn all sorts of new things.

But pause for a moment to look at what they mean by ‘nearby’, and ‘BACKYARD’. This burst of light is actually coming from an exploding star in a galaxy, the article tells us, not merely ‘far far away’, but 21 million light years away,

That means the light arriving in our telescopes today must have set off on its journey 21 million years ago – so the event we are witnessing from our ‘ringside seat’ actually happened 21 million years ago. Which, I see from Wikipedia when I look it up, was the Serravalian age of the Miocene on Earth, when a little monkey-like creature, Anoiapithecus, one of the earliest hominids, was living in what is now Spain.

One of the science facts I remember from childhood is that light travels at a hundred and eighty six thousand miles a second. So the light from that explosion, which outshines the light of the entire galaxy it comes from (galaxies are big, bright things – think Milky Way with its one hundred thousand million stars – Oh no, perhaps don’t) the light from that explosion has been travelling that distance – most of the way to the Moon – every second for all of that time. And although the article tells us in passing that astronomers see thousands of supernovae every year (I did go back and check this) this one is extraordinarily near to us. Is your mind boggling yet? Mine certainly is.

Let’s return to Douglas Adams’ Hitchhikers’ Guide to put it in a nutshell:

‘The simple truth is that interstellar distances will not fit in the human imagination’

Quite.

Which brings me to a thought of mine own which I think may be worth sharing.

My generation grew up during the postwar years full of optimism about scientific advances and in particular the much-heralded era of space travel.

1950 – cover of the first Eagle

In the early 1950s the nearest thing to a comic our parents allowed us to read was the Eagle. My favourite character was Dan Dare, Pilot of the Future, rocketing about in his space ship and combatting the evil Mekon, a green, disembodied head, who commanded his alien space-squadrons, crewed by evil ‘Treens’ (also green), from the control room of his flagship while floating about on something a bit like an avocado dish. Wonderful stuff.

When the family went to America in 1954 I was engrossed in a radio series called ‘Journey into Space’. The plucky heroes of which had just arrived on Mars when we had to head for Southampton and the Queen Mary. And we left on the very morning after the episode when they discovered they were not alone. I had asked my friend Derek to promise to tell me what happened. But he never did. (I still don’t know.)

1953 – note the wonderfully streamlined space ships!

After arriving in America one of my favourite presents, if not the favourite present, was a book called Rockets, Jets, Guided Missiles and SpaceShips. I came back to it over and over again for years, and kept making feeble attempts to draw my own space ships. I was pretty sure I still had the book somewhere in the loft, but when I looked just now it seems to have gone. So this image, which must be of the original edition I had, is from the web..

Then of course we grew up through the whole Sputnik, Moon landings, Space Shuttle, saga which gripped our generation and continues today with various tycoons taking joy-rides into ‘space’ and Elon Musk seriously suggesting he would like to take a trip to Mars.

But behind all this it seems to me there has been a basic assumption that we are on the threshold of something called the ‘Space Age’, when mankind will have learned to travel between the stars. And so we have people discussing – not least in New Scientist – various technologies for powering a space craft to another star (and then slowing it down again when it gets there don’t forget) and different ways in which human passengers might be accommodated, preserved, entertained even, for the vast expanses of time required to make the journey. Here is such a discussion.

Now the realisation that has only recently occurred to me, and which I would love to hear a convincing reason to doubt because it is so disillusioning, is this:

Quite simply, everything is so mind-bogglingly far apart in space that even if we did make the colossal effort, investment, human sacrifice, etc. that would be required to send an expedition to, say, proxima-centauri, the nearest star – a mere 4.24 light years away – we would find ourselves when we got there just as far away from everywhere else as we were when we started.

All the other stars (don’t even think about all the other galaxies!) would be no closer to us than they were when we left Earth. I don’t know about you, but after a lifetime of what I now realise are unrealistic imaginings, I find that a thoroughly sobering thought.

But this is surely yet another reason to use our industry, enterprise, human genius, and all the rest of it, to look after the world we’ve got before it’s too late. The idea, which you do see seriously mooted, that we might somehow survive by moving somewhere else, ain’t going to happen, even if it wouldn’t have been a nightmare for all the other obvious reasons..


I once explained to a very young grandson that when I was his age we didn’t know whether there were men on Mars. His reply was disarmingly sensible, ‘But you must have known it was very unlikely’.

I’m afraid it’s time to grow up.

Outer Hebrides – 7 – Going home – and general comments on the EV experience.

Our trip: 1,700 miles driving – with four ferry crossings.

That Thursday morning we had a breakfast of muesli and kippers, checked out, and drove away, not actually ‘without a backward glance’, because I stopped for this photo.

Strangely quiet and soulless hotel – in spite of its four stars

The 20 miles back down to Stornoway only took us half an hour and as check-in at the ferry terminal was at 1pm we had lots of time.

As ever, the first thing to do before we could relax was get the car plugged into a charger. We had driven 100 miles since we topped up the day before and wanted to arrive on the mainland with a full battery ready for the drive south the next morning. So we made our way back to the same Chargepoint Scotland installation we had used before – in the big, free car park half a mile east of the town centre. We again found both the main units free, which was lucky because the middle one hadn’t worked last time, but again the other one started charging straight away. As you see from the photo, there was a white Renault Zoe on the smaller unit at the end – a car with a much smaller range which we could only think must have been a local.

The unit in the middle had failed to connect the previous day.

As we started into town Lesley had another of her clever ideas. We had a vague memory that the nice people from Hebridean Hopscotch, our tour organiser, were based somewhere near here, and sure enough, when we looked it up we found the office was only a couple of hundred yards down the road. So we called in as we went past to introduce ourselves and give them some feedback on the trip and the places we’d stayed. i.e. the two B&Bs way out in front, followed by the hotels in reverse order of star-rating. It became apparent that it was still quite unusual for someone to attempt the trip in an electric car, possibly even a first for them, and the agent, with her lovely Hebridean accent, seemed relieved that we had had no significant trouble.

We then had time to kill in the town, so we had coffee in a quirky coffee shop and watched a couple of lads busking on their bagpipes.

Stornoway buskers

Ferry loading, as ever, was straightforward and we left the car on the car deck to find comfortable seats for the crossing.

It was a modern, well-appointed ship and the observation lounge was hushed and comfortable, with just the right amount of gentle motion from the waves. Only half the length of the Oban-Castlebay crossing, the hour and forty minutes passed very easily.

Now having completed our Hebridean Hopscotch itinerary, we had booked this night via Booking.com at Harbour House, a large, modern B&B just up the road from the Ullapool ferry terminal, where we, along with a number of other car-loads off the boat, were greeted with a convivial dram of Scotch.

It was a lovely, sunny evening as we walked the half mile to the seafront for supper at the Ferry Boat Inn, We had only come a short distance south on the ferry but noticed a completely different feel to the place from Lewis, partly because of the vastly improved weather no doubt, but in spite of road works all along the seafront front it struck us as a much brighter and greener place than the greyness of Stornoway.

Cruise liner in Ullapool Bay from the window of our hotel.
The back of the hotel – leaving in the morning

It was a four hour drive from Ullapool to Glasgow, and as we bypassed Inverness and went on through Aviemore the road became gradually larger and busier.

We had thought we would break the journey and try out one of the numerous Chargepoint Scotland stations indicated in and around Perth and Stirling. But actually when we looked at the detail on the app only some them were the CCS kind we needed and those seemed to be well off the route and in places like multi-story car parks. So when the navigation system showed us that we had enough charge to get to a Tesla supercharger we took the easy way out and told it to take us there.

Which it did, automatically starting the process of conditioning the battery for supercharging (heating it, we think) when we were about twenty minutes out. Very cool.

The supercharger installation at Motherwell

The Motherwell installation, near Glasgow, turned out to be situated on land owned by the Dakota Eurocentral Hotel, a grand establishment indeed. Signs by every pump warned you to go inside and enter the car’s registration, or pay a large penalty fee. All rather odd – but obviously the deal. So in we went to the dimly-lit and rather pretentious interior and sat for a while eating expensive sandwiches with their crusts trimmed off and drinking expensive lime and soda.

Never was it more apparent that Tesla ownership gives you membership of an exclusive and privileged club, which is fine for us, but hardly a model for EV charging infrastructure in general. For us it was something of a guilty relief after negotiating public chargers, even in relatively-enlightened Scotland, to get back to the confidence-inspiring simplicity of just backing up, opening the charge-point flap, plugging in, and walking away. Leaving the car to draw its 125kW or so, instead of the 35kW or so we had become used to – but that was only one, and perhaps the least, of the advantages.

After that we drove on along the motorway through lowland Scotland towards Carlisle and the border. A beautiful drive on a spacious road with widely separated carriageways, which follows the route I had several times travelled by rail. During these long stages we entertained ourselves by listening to all nine hours of Jim Broadbent reading Rachel Fry’s delightful The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry, which suited us perfectly.

Driving through lowland Scotland

The M6 through the hills or northern England is one of our favourite roads and we stopped for the night near its highest point with the Lake District on the horizon, at the isolated Shap Wells hotel, again booked, this time at short notice, through Booking.com.

It was a large, elegant, traditional hotel set in beautiful countryside with its own wooded glen alive with waterfalls and red squirrels. We loved it and its friendly staff.

Stopping to top up a final time at Keele services superchargers, the next morning, we found ourselves diverted down the M5 because of an accident on the M40. And so came home by an unfamiliar but very beautiful route through the Cotswold Hills.

It had been a fabulous trip.


The EV experience.

Many chargers indicated on the islands

Our experience is that the car doesn’t go as far as it says it will. Although the nominal range is 330 miles, in practice we looked for chargers at least every 250. Our experience of the Tesla network had given us great confidence, but were much more cautious when we were using public chargers because we weren’t sure they would work

This certainly applied while we were on the Islands where we tried to keep the battery close to half full. Which meant finding a charger every other day. And there is no denying that this became a background preoccupation. I have no doubt, however, that others would be more courageous than we were.

Scotland’s national public charging network, Chargeplace Scotland, with 1,000 units and counting. This is far more advanced than the jungle of competing networks in England. It has a unified payment system (Hallelujah!) either via the app, via the website, or using a contactless card. We had sent for the card in advance of our trip and set up linking to a credit card.

So – the Chargeplace Scotland app shows what looks like an ample provision on the Islands – three, for a start, on Barra where we arrived, two of them in Castlebay itself and one of those outside the council offices, literally across the road from our hotel.

It sounded great, and we had come all the way from Abington services south of Glasgow expecting it would be easy. But as I described in the blog, I couldn’t make that unit work and had to go down to the quay and plug in to the more modern-looking one there. Which worked fine, very much to my relief.

And that turned out to be the pattern. There were two kinds of unit, a smaller one – which I never got to work – with a minimalist display and requiring your own connecting cable, and a bigger one in a blue livery with its own cables, often sited at a ferry terminal, which did work, sometimes after one or two false starts. The latter kind delivered around 35kW and topped the car up in about an hour – coffee or walk-around. Twice we found the units occupied, but we got round that by coming back later.

One point seems almost too obvious to mention, but is actually important: unlike a conventional filling station, these installations are always unmanned. And there is never anybody around who understands them. To be fair, there is an emergency help line, and if we had tried that we might feel differently.

The bottom line is that we never actually had a serious worry about charging, but it was sometimes frustrating. Even in more-enlightened Scotland we basically haven’t got it right yet if this is to be the future.

In every other respect driving the the Tesla was an absolute dream. It is incredibly comfortable, quiet and smooth. The effortless power wafted us up the steepest of slopes without the car showing the slightest sign of noticing the difference. Light years away from the changing of gears and the revving of engines.

The large central information screen constantly provided a wealth of information, including a zoomable satellite rendering of the country we were travelling through, with points of interest highlighted and labelled.

Compared with driving our old diesel Skoda – by previous standards a refined and sophisticated car – it feels like a quantum leap forward.

The Sat-nav showing our position at the Butt of Lewis Lighthouse.

Bottom line – cost…

Here is a schedule of the chrging charges we incured. Curiously, the full top-up in Castlebay, after we arrived on the islands, never appeared on the Chargeplace Scotland account at all. And the one we had at Tarbert Ferry Terminal (in the rain) wasn’t billed! We certainly had both.

Summary of charging charges for the trip

Outer Hebrides – 6 – Isle of Lewis

Tuesday 16th – Journey from the Harris Hotel up through the island to Borve House Hotel, Lewis

Annotated Google Map showing sites we visited on our way up to the Butt of Lewis Lighthouse.

We weren’t really prepared for what a large place Lewis is. Or for the fact that once you get much above the half of the island which is Harris, most of the interest in Lewis appears to be round the edges.

Although on arriving from the Southern Islands we had been immediately struck by the evidence of increased prosperity – almost none of the deserted or ruined buildings, almost none of the abandoned and rusting farm and other machinery that on the whole tourists don’t care to photograph..

But after the beautiful hills and mountains of Harris, the central area of Lewis appears to be a huge expanse of more or less uniform peat bog. Which has its own fascination, but would be an heroic trek for anyone determined to complete the Hebridean Way on foot. Bicyclists were a different matter, although for them it is tough going as well, but there were a great many of them doing the trip.

Many miles of road like this on Lewis

Ancient sites along the way spoke of the milder climate in the Hebrides many centuries ago. The.Standing Stones of Callanish are 4,000 years old – older than Stonehenge – and the visitor centre and museum at the site did a good job of telling the various theories about the significance and purpose of the site. Two avenues of stones, one long and one short, crossed at what was clearly some sort of ceremonial centre. We checked the orientation of the long axis out of curiosity and found it ran towards the SSE. The stones themselves were more of the ancient gneiss rock, naturally grained and patterned and very beautiful, especially when the sun broke through the scudding clouds.

We were told that the visitor centre has been awarded a six million pound grant for upgrading, which was a bit eyebrow-raising. Let’s hope the stones are not going to be roped off from visitors as Stonehenge has been – although of course that was for excellent reasons. Progress, and all that.

Please expand the above pictures to get a getter idea.

The second visitor attraction along the way was the Iron Age tower of Carloway Broch. A mere 2,000 years old, this is a surprisingly sophisticated structure of double-skinned dry stone walls, with staircases inside them giving access to what were once upper floors.

This site was even less regimented than the standing stones, and you could go inside through the very low entrance, through another doorway opposite into the space between the walls. and climb up the first flight of the staircase.

It had turned into a sunny afternoon and the close turf was delightful to walk on. There was a steady, spread-out stream of visitors, but I was the only one who climbed the hillside behind to see and photograph the view from above.

From there we pressed on, past what was to be our hotel for the next two nights, to the northernmost point of our journey – the Butt of Lewis lighthouse. After mile upon mile through almost uninhabited country we came to a string of relatively heavily populated habitations at the very top of Lewis: South and North Dell, Swainbost, Habost, Lional and Eoropaidh. We wondered what on earth so many people could find to do up there, but were assured by a local that employment there was good.

The Butt of Lewis is known as one of the wildest and windiest places in the British Isles, but we found it, and its lighthouse, on a beautiful day. It was a lovely place, with intricately-folded metamorphic gneiss rocks, crashing waves, and seabirds, which we recognised as fulmars, roosting on the sheer rock faces in pairs who seemed to spend much of the time billing, though not actually cooing.

Having sat and walked on the short grass and talked to the cosmopolitan visitors, we started back along the road and almost immediately stopped above a little bay to which we descended and Lesley had a paddle in the sea.

The hotel was rather strange and did not live up to its star rating for us. Although it probably ticked all the boxes for a modern building it had fire doors every few paces in narrow corridors with no pictures on the walls, and for us it seemed soulless. Certainly in comparison with the more traditional hotels we stayed at and no comparison at all to the two B&Bs further south.

Wednesday 17th

The weather was deteriorating by the next morning, and we set off to have a look at Stornoway. With a population of around 9,000 it is by far the largest town in the Outer Hebridean chain. The general feel was much more like a mainland town, and a prosperous one at that, with streets of large well-built houses.

But at the same time much of it felt quite run down, and quite grey, It may have been the weather, and another frustrating experience with a charger, but we felt quite dispirited. But we found a Guardian, and the same day’s at that, and sat reading it in the lovely public library which had a delightful young woman librarian who allowed us to use the toilets which were marked ‘staff only’. Which was a good thing because the only public toilets were closed for renovation.

With the car fully charged – yes, I’m afraid I have to admit that doing this trip with an electric car, even one with a big battery like ours, charging does form a constant background preoccupation, and I would be misleading you if I didn’t include this aspect – with the car fully charged, we made our way to the castle and its modern museum, with a film of Hebridean landscape scenes projected onto three large walls, with no narration – just the sounds of nature. The museum continued with well-curated displays of aspects of Hebridean and Gaelic culture and history. Then we had a light lunch in the excellent cafeteria.

Heading west across the moor, on 17 miles of narrow, single-track road, we came to the village of Gearrannan – where a picturesque group of old Black Houses has been conserved to illustrate the very simple conditions in which the crofters lived, often with their livestock at the downhill end – helping to heat the building. At the end of the winter they would apparently take down the end wall, clear out the manure and bedding, and spread it on the fields.

The last families were moved into council accommodation as recently as the 1970s and fortunately it occurred to someone to preserve the village as a record.

The interior of one of the houses has been fully restored, with even a peat fire burning brightly in the grate,

At the other end of the building there was a demonstration of the weaving of Harris Tweed.- a traditional occupation of the villagers. This wonderful character was there six days a week patiently demonstrating to a constant stream of inquisitive visitors.

In the evening we decided to eschew the hotel restaurant, braving the rain to drive 10 minutes up island to The Cross Inn which was situated in what was little more than a scatter of houses called, unsurprisingly, Cross.

The Cross Inn

This was a warm, cheerful and bustling place and suited us fine. As elsewhere, it was a perfectly decent meal, though scarcely memorable. I finished off with a single malt, in valediction to an extraordinary trip, and Lesley drove us back to the hotel.

Completed in the next post…

The Outer Hebrides – 5 – Harris

Harris is roughly the southern half of the northernmost, and by far the largest, island in the Outer Hebridean chain. Quite why the upper and lower halves of this island have different names – Lewis and Harris respectively – is far from clear (nobody suggests England and Scotland are different islands). But anyway, the part of Harris you arrive on from the South is connected to the rest of Harris by a narrow isthmus, and it is there that the small town of Tarbert, and the Harris Hotel we stayed at, are situated.

Another delightful contrast: this is an almost old-fashioned hotel, with high ceilings, gracious and comfortable public spaces, white linen on the tables, well-maintained gardens in front, and so on.

Tarbert itself is a slightly run-down sort of place. It is yet another ferry terminal, and road works to improve the marshalling area, next to the impressive distillery with its hundreds of casks (presumably empty) lined up outside, rather dominated the walk from the hotel to the centre, such as it was.

Having set out boldly without coats to explore the place we only avoided being caught in a heavy rain squall by walking back as rapidly as we could.

Sunday 14th – The Golden Road

Before exploring Northern Harris we decided to go back and take the ‘Golden Road’ which winds along the eastern coast of South Harris and which some more knowledgeable travellers had chosen as their route up from the ferry the day before. It was a stunning drive:

Driving along the ‘Golden Road’

From there we re-joined the main road and headed for a charging station, marked on the app as being in a small commercial area high above Seilebost beach.

This charger turned out to be the same type of smaller model, requiring the car’s on-board connecting cable, which I had failed to make work in Castlebay. And once again I found myself landed in endlessly circling instructions on its little screen, just as a perversely-timed rain flurry took the rest of the fun out of the occasion.

After which experience, even though the battery was still half full, topping it up became a priority. So when we got back to Tarbert the first thing we did was put the car on a charger – successfully. But another perfectly-timed downpour soaked me as I did connected up so that we were thoroughly wet when we darted into the hotel opposite in search of coffee. The staff inside declined any payment for the cakes we chose with our coffee, so we must have looked in a pretty sorry state as we hung our things on the radiator to dry.

Our Eilean Glas lighthouse walk on Skalpay island

The forecast for the rest of the day was fine so we decided to visit the Eileen Glas lighthouse, strongly recommended by one of the couples we had got to know through several meetings as we moved up the islands. But we misunderstood their description and assumed they had approached it via one of the walks we found on the Walkhighlands website.

So basically we underestimated what we were taking on, to the extent that I persuaded Lesley we wouldn’t need the coffee, water and snacks that we usually carried on our walks. But after walking for an hour and a half and nearly three miles of rough, steeply up and down peat hags, there was no sign of the lighthouse and I was wondering whether it would be more sensible to turn back.

…which would have been a big mistake – Fortunately Lesley was made of tougher stuff and we made one more ascent to a cairn from which we could at last see, not only the lighthouse, but the track our advisers had actually used which would afford us an easier, if still lengthy, way back to the car.

At last – the lighthouse and the track. (Skye on the horizon)

The couple who have owned and managed the lighthouse for forty years, staff the café there every day of the summer, living in isolation and having to carry everything half a mile from the road. Definitely something to enjoy while it lasts.

Red dots show we missed out the bit along the coast!

The walk back to the car along another winding and hilly road was tiring and we were very glad not to miss the way back to the car. Nearly seven miles in those conditions is quite enough for us now, but we were so very glad to have done it.

The Outer Hebrides – 4 – Benbecula & North Uist

I have to tell you about the places we stay, because they are such an important part of the trip. We had been assured by both Margaret in South Uist and by the assistant in the Hebridean Jewellery Centre, when we told them where we were heading next, that we ‘would be alright with Mary’. And so indeed we were.

It later transpired that one of her two dogs had died at the vet’s the day we arrived (and the other hadn’t got out of its bed since) but she gave us the most wonderful welcome in spite of this. Another tremendous character, she had simply not missed a trick in providing facilities for our comfort and convenience, including a no-touch automatic soap-dispenser in the bathroom, if you please, and a power hub with no less than six power sockets and four USB charging points. Wi-fi, as everywhere we stay, is a given, and the password is almost the first item in every welcome.

Mary’s Borve Guest House logo was on welcome card, biros, wrappers round table napkins, and even on the disposable paper covering for the fresh butter in the pat. She told us she had burnt it onto the wooden table mats herself with a kind of soldering iron as something to do during lockdown (no photo – sorry!).

As before, we went for supper both evenings to a hotel about half a mile down the road – this one was the Dark Isles Hotel. And this time it looked a little further and we drove, offering a lift to two fellow guests the first evening, for which they were very grateful. We shared a table with them, two agreeable English ladies, who revealed knowledge of gin.

The excellent waiter was Romanian, and when we expressed surprise that he had found his way to South Uist he said he really liked it here, having tried Bath for a number of years. The dining room was a busy place and the sound of wild revelry burst through the door from the public bar every time it opened. Our waiter explained cheerfully that it was noisy music and noisy people. They were still at it when we left. And the second night was quieter.

The Dark Isles Hotel where we went for supper is in the distance.

Saturday 13th

We thought it would be wise to top up the car so, once we had had Mary’s sumptuous breakfast, we started the day by finding the charging unit marked on the Chargepoint Scotland app as being, improbably, in front of the school next to the hotel where we had eated the night before (which would obviously have been a good time to use it!) and found it already occupied. So we set off for the day up the island of Benbecula, where, as on South Uist, the mainly single track but beautifully-surfaced road wound and undulated through relatively flat land studded with innumerable lochs.

Reaching and crossed the causeway onto North Uist we made straight for the ferry port of Lochmaddy where we were directed by a workman to the charger down by the quay where upgrade works were in progress, so we were able to leave the car on it for an hour. Leaving, as it turned out, Lesley’s phone in it, so that, amongst the obvious communication difficulties, the car ‘thought’ she was still in it (Bluetooth, in case you wondered) and never locked. Not that that seemed the slightest danger in these parts.

Anyway, we repaired to a lovely little, modern, gallery, shop and museum a short distance away, where we installed ourselves while I walked a little further up the hill than I expected to the local shop in search of a newspaper (Lesley didn’t know where I’d gone, hence the aforementioned communication difficulty). Reaching the tiny general store I learned that the plane with the nationals had not yet arrived from the mainland, so I came back with a Stornoway Gazette, from which we read of chaos in the Caledonian MacBrane ferry services disrupting the tourist industry which was now to be hit by a savage hike in business rates.

From Lochmaddy, with the ring of confidence afforded by 300 miles in the battery, we continued anticlockwise around the top of the island towards another bird reserve. On the way I suddenly recognised a conspicuous tower on an island as having been next to a farm on North Uist on a recent Countryfile on BBC television, featured because it had been taken over and was being run, unaided, by an utterly-extraordinary 17 year old lad.

As seen on Countryfile

As I stood by the car to take the above picture a woman with a stout walking pole and tweed headband came striding up the hill and I couldn’t resist sharing my discovery. She was delighted: “Oh, you mean Archie!”. It turned out she was a local and it was obvious they were proud of him.

When we got to the bird reserve we happened to be comparing notes about the birds with another local, and when I mentioned that we had seen the famous farm back down the road he said that the woman running the campsite at the reserve was Archie’s Mum. Small world. Lovely people.

Anyway, we had a superb walk around a complicated shoreline in very strong wind. Here we did see a lot of birds, a shag and a number of eider ducks on rocks, and lapwings, greylag geese, arctic terns and great flocks of dunlin which we tried not to disturb on the grassy slopes. And turnstones on the shore.

It was quite a tough walk for us and we got back to the car glowing from the wind.

Sunday 14th

Saying goodbye to Borve Guest House we drove back up through Benbecula, anticlockwise around North Uist past Lockmaddy and right at the top across yet another causeway onto the small island of Berneray where there was another ferry terminal from which we were going to cross the Sound of Harris in the early afternoon.

Wich left us plenty of time, on yet another sunny day, for another coastal walk.

Joining the ferry queue early I passed the time chatting to group of bikers about the practicalities of EV motoring, agreeing that it, or something like it, had to be the future, but they hadn’t got it entirely sorted yet,

According to my friend Alec, who skippered our four cruises in the past, the Sound of Harris. with its profusion of obstacles, involves probably the most intricate pilotage on the entire Western coast. The ferry, he told me, has to make 25 changes of course in the crossing, which was very apparent as we watched from high above the car deck (still having to cancel the car alarm with the app!)

Rocks dead ahead – time for another change of course

We were third car off the ferry (that’s the front of our car in the picture – next to the bikes) and drove up the mountainous and incredibly beautiful west coast, stopping with others to look down on the beaches of Seilebost and Luskentyre.

to Tarbert where we checked in to the Harris Hotel.

Continues in the next post…